How to highlight and annotate a PDF on a Mac
Why highlighting fails on a scan
The highlighter needs text to attach to. In a born-digital PDF it finds the word boundaries and lays a neat band over exactly the right glyphs. In a scanned page there are no glyphs — the page is an image — so there is nothing to snap to and you get a rough rectangle wherever you dragged.
Live Text muddies this further: you can select words on a scan, which feels like text, but the highlighter still has nothing in the file to anchor to. If you want proper highlighting on a scanned document, it needs OCR first. After that the highlighter behaves normally.
The annotation sidebar nobody opens
View → Highlights and Notes turns a marked-up PDF into a list. Every highlight and note in document order, clickable. For anyone reading papers or reviewing a contract this is the feature that makes Preview worth using, and it is hidden two levels into a menu.
Notes, text boxes and which to use
A note is a comment attached to a point on the page. It collapses to a small marker, shows on hover, and carries an author name — the right choice for feedback someone else will read.
A text box is content placed on the page. It looks like part of the document, which is what you want for filling in a form and exactly what you do not want for a comment, because the recipient cannot tell your words from the original's.
Annotations are portable, mostly
Highlights, notes, shapes and underlines made in Preview are standard PDF annotations. Adobe Reader, Chrome, iOS Files and essentially everything else reads them, and they stay editable. This is better interoperability than many paid apps manage — some store markup in a private sidecar format that no other reader can see.
The exception is that a reader can also remove them, since they sit above the page content rather than in it. File → Export as PDF flattens annotations into the page when you want them permanent, at the cost of making them no longer editable — including by you.
Review on an iPad, finish on the Mac
Annotations written by Preview are read and written by the Files app and by Books on iOS, so a document highlighted with a Pencil on an iPad opens on the Mac with the markup intact, and the sidebar lists it. The round trip works because both ends are writing the same standard annotations.
Step by step
- Show the Markup toolbar
View → Show Markup Toolbar, or the pen icon. - For highlighting, just select text and press ⌘⌃H
No tool switching needed. Hold the mouse on the highlight button to pick underline or strikethrough instead. - Use notes for comments, not text boxes
A note collapses to a marker and carries the author. A text box sits on the page like printed text. - Read your annotations back in the sidebar
View → Highlights and Notes lists every annotation in the document in order.
Our iOS app for exactly this. Runs on your device — no account, no tracking.